Even complicated and confusing topics will be easily developed and covered if you request our help writing an essay. Place an order today!

To illustrate and exemplify the relationship between power and representation in development critique, this section analyses a television commercial for a major international non-governmental organization. The advert starts by showing a poverty-stricken girl, emaciated, gaunt, with a distant glazed look on her face. The narrator, an English male, reads

Asha would ask you something if she could. She’d ask you to save her life, but she’s too exhausted. She’s starving. She’d look you in the eye; she’d ask again if she thought someone, somewhere had the heart to help.

Over footage of other starving children, accompanied by a slow, melancholy piano, the narrator continues:

Please, help a child like Asha right now. We know what it takes to save a child’s life. The solutions are simple, but we need your help . . . Asha can’t ask you, but we can. Please will you stop children dying?

While Asha’s story provokes feelings of pity, compassion and perhaps anger, disgust or guilt, these immediate reactions obscure deeper critical inquiry. The advert describes Asha’s plight in great detail, but it leaves many other questions unanswered. First, where does Asha live? To many viewers, Asha’s surroundings and skin colour suggest somewhere in Africa, but by leaving this unstated the advert places her in a vague, stereotypical Third World context. Second, why is she starving? Is it due to political oppression, or perhaps fluctuations in food prices caused by global markets? By not addressing this, the advert suggests this condition is an intrinsic or inevitable feature of living conditions in the ‘Third World’. Even Asha’s name raises certain questions: would the advert have the same impact if she were called Susan or Jennifer?

What is clear is that Asha’s life is deficient, even pitiable in nearly every respect, but everything else is vague and unstated. Furthermore, the audience is continually reminded that Asha cannot speak for herself; instead, we must rely on the narrator to describe her plight. Thus, in this relationship the narrator (and by extension the development organization), hold all the power: they are able to put forward a representation that is remarkably one-sided: poverty is focused upon to the exclusion of all else.

Through this advert, one clearly sees the issues raised by poststructuralists such as Escobar (1995). Representation is asymmetric: the object of development (Asha) is represented by the narrator, who grounds his authority in knowledge (‘We know what it takes to save a child’s life’). As Trudell (2009) notes, the primary feature of the development discourse is deficiency, often to the exclusion of all else. Thus, Asha is described only in terms of her problems and deficits. According to poststructuralists, the claim to save children like Asha is ultimately bankrupt; instead the concept of development is used as a guide to perpetuate a relationship of power and control.

How are issues of poverty and development portrayed in the media? How does this reflect upon the international development sector as a whole?

testimonials icon
FHS 2400 Test 5 -- Chapters 9-11 Unless otherwise noted, there is only one correct answer for each question.  You...
testimonials icon
Hello, I am looking for someone to write an essay on 8. It needs to be at least 500 words.For example, the inhabitants could have cooperated...
testimonials icon
RA 1—Aligning Organizational GoalsBackgroundWith proper goal alignment, each person within an organization can clearly see the dire...
testimonials icon
 You really like the concept of web-based computing and want to use as many web-based programs as possible. Write a brief paragraph discussing the...
testimonials icon
SolutionThe number of protons is always equal to the number of electrons in each and every atom in theperiodic table. Therefore, Number of Protons =...
testimonials icon
Running Head: PODCAST ANALYSIS1Podcast AnalysisInstitutional AffiliationDatePODCAST ANALYSIS2A brand is that what you do and the method you apply in...
testimonials icon
Chosen Company: Starbucks This assignment requires you to compile Parts 1, 2, and 3 into one document, which will be your final repo...
testimonials icon
Introduction to Women’s StudiesFinal AssignmentThe written portion of the assignment shou...
testimonials icon
  Is this the question you were looking for? Place your Ord...
testimonials icon
Week 5 Discussion 1Capital Investment EvaluationSelect one of the capital investment evaluation methods described in Chapter 10 of yo...
testimonials icon
In this lesson you will practice creating a balance sheet and cash flow statement. You will apply this...

Other samples, services and questions:

Calculate Price

When you use PaperHelp, you save one valuable — TIME

You can spend it for more important things than paper writing.

Approx. price
$65
Order a paper. Study better. Sleep tight. Calculate Price!
Created with Sketch.
Calculate Price
Approx. price
$65